FindLaw | For the Public | For Small Business | For Legal Professionals | Find a Lawyer
   
Search Writ
Front Page
Special Coverage
  Hurricane Katrina
  Enron
  Tribunals
  Terrorism
Archives
  Columnists
  Guest Columnists
Law Students
Book Reviews
Message Boards
 
 Legal News
US Law
Supreme Court
Politics
Civil Rights
Crime
Tort
Business
Labor
Tech & IP
Environment
 
 Investigations
 International
 Entertainment
 Sports
 News Wires
 Legal Documents
 FindLaw Features
Supreme Court Center
Recent Case Law
Cases & Codes
FindLaw Library
Legal Dictionary
MY FindLaw
Print This | Email This
----
CHALLENGES FOR THE SUPREME COURT IN THE WAKE OF TERRORISM:
Allowing Greater Federal Power, And Minimizing Church/State Ties

By EDWARD LAZARUS
----
Tuesday, Oct. 02, 2001

In recent years, the opening of the Supreme Court term has been the focus of considerable fanfare and discussion. This year, the event passes as a footnote to news of much greater urgency. That is entirely as it should be. But the Court may take a high-profile role again someday soon.

For now, the pressing questions all relate to how the other branches of government — those charged with making foreign and economic policy, and enacting the laws that govern the way we investigate and address terrorism — will respond to the events of September 11. Eventually, however, the Court will be required to assess some of the legislative responses to the tragedy. Then we will see the Court's finest hour, or, possibly, its darkest.

The President and Legislature Rise to the Occasion

The crisis created by the terrorist attack has had a dramatic and salutary effect on both the Executive and Congress. President Bush, to his credit, has quickly abandoned both the narrow partisanship and the unilateralist foreign policy of his Administration's first months. In their place, he has set an inspiring, bipartisan, internationalist agenda of eliminating terrorism root and branch.

Similarly, in Congress, a wide-ranging group of Democrats and Republicans have left behind the small-minded, acrimonious debate over capital gains tax cuts and social security lockboxes. In its place, they have moved on to an urgent and probing discussion of the large issues of national and economic security that now loom ominously about us.

It is too soon to know, of course, whether the new way of doing business in Washington will produce wise and effective policies. But it not to soon to say that, at least for a time, the higher calling of a national emergency has shamed our elected institutions of government out of their endless routine of shallow political maneuvering.

The Challenge to the Court's Federalism

Will the Court respond as positively? We can only hope so.

Eventually, inescapably, the Court will be drawn into the war against terrorism that Bush has declared. Congress is almost certain to give law enforcement greater authority to wiretap. It may also give law enforcement new authority to monitor the Internet or to detain and question foreign nationals. In the next year or two, the Court will be called upon to pass on the constitutionality of all such measures.

What Do You Think? Message Boards


Edward Lazarus writes about, practices, and teaches law in Los Angeles. A former federal prosecutor, he is the author of two books, most recently Closed Chambers: The Rise, Fall, and Future of the Modern Supreme Court.

 Book Reviews
Anthony Lewis
Freedom for the Thought That We Hate: A Biography of the First Amendment

- by ELAINE CASSEL
 Subscribe to RSS
 Columnists
Akhil Amar
Vikram Amar
Sherry Colb
John Dean
Michael C. Dorf
Joanna Grossman
Marci Hamilton
Julie Hilden
Edward Lazarus
Joanne Mariner
Anita Ramasastry
Anthony Sebok
 
Guest Columnists
 Writ Forum


Message Boards

 

  FindLaw.com LEGAL NEWS:  Top Headlines · Supreme Court · Commentary · Crime · Cyberspace · International
US FEDERAL LAW:  Constitution · Codes · Supreme Court Opinions · Circuit Opinions
US STATE LAW:  State Constitutions · State Codes · Case Law
RESEARCH:  Dictionary · Forms · LawCrawler · Library · Summaries of Law
LEGAL SUBJECTS:  Constitutional · Intellectual Property · Criminal · Labor · more...
GOVERNMENT RESOURCES:  US Federal · US State · Directories · more...
INTERNATIONAL RESOURCES:  Country Guides · Trade · World Constitutions · more...
COMMUNITY:   Message Boards · Newsletters · Greedy Associates Boards
TOOLS:  Office · Calendar · Email · West WorkSpace · FirmSites
Advertising Info · Add URL · Help · Comments Jobs@FindLaw · Site Map
Company | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer Copyright © 1994-2008 FindLaw